Study finds abstinence-only teaching effective in delaying teen sex


Score one for the abstinence movement: a study, published in the Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine,¬†found abstinence only teaching helped delay the age teens are having sex by as much as two years. Now, before you start cursing at the fact that the religious right is going to use this study to keep funding their veiled religious sexual education program, it’s important to note even the people conducting the study stressed abstinence programs are not effective in the long term. That’s because most programs misinform kids about various forms of birth control, and this is one of the main reasons why teen pregnancy rates in the US are so high.

… more than half of the students who were taught about safe sex and condom use reported having intercourse by the two-year mark, and more than 40 percent of students who received either an eight- or 12-hour lesson incorporating both abstinence education and safe sex reported having sex at two years.

So basically, abstinence only programs might delay the age kids have sex, but it doesn’t do a very good job at preventing these same kids from having babies when they are way too young.

I’m not actually surprised with the study, since it reflects the same studies which have been conducted regarding drug education programs; it turns out if you teach kids about their options, they are more likely to be curious and try them. The difference, of course, is they are less likely to make POOR decisions, which is really what education is all about. Look, you can’t stop kids from having sex (even less so than drugs); they’re hardwired by billions of years of evolution to crave it. Failing to teach kids about their options, however, is the real irresponsible thing here, and parents are sacrificing their children’s long term future in the vain hope they’ll “wait a little longer”. By delaying the inevitable and being deceptive about contraceptives and condom use, parents may have a little peace of mind, but it certainly isn’t worth the trade off.

NOTE: Turns out that it’s not even an “abstinence only” program they studied, but it was actually part of a broader sex ed program that encouraged kids to wait until they were ready while still providing information about proper birth control. This probably won’t do anything to dissuade religious folks from thinking their childish programs work, but that’s not really news, is it?

(props to James for pointing this out)

Comments (5)

  • avatar

    Scott

    1) I’m all for having kids delay sex until they’re mature enough, which is what this experiment taught, not the hardcore the hardcore wait-until-marriage, type. http://tinyurl.com/yjmaq7s

    2) We should be more concerned with , not with when kids are having sex, but making sure they’re doing it safely: not getting STDs, or becoming pregnant, so having them wait isn’t the ideal goal.

  • avatar

    CybrgnX

    Reading post like this always makes me happy that my kids started their education in england where sex and drug education starts at kindergarden and progress thru the years.
    My daughter told me in her 20s that one reason she was a virgin for so long is because her 1st sex course showed the entire birth process. And when the baby started squeezing out the vagina, she looks down at herself, looked at the movie and stated “There aint no way anything that big is coming out my bottom!!!” the other reason is that in high school all the boys were terrified of her ability to kick their asses! so they never asked her out on dates.
    But good sex ed at an early age can have more effect on sex activity then the scared schites want to believe. I think its the fact they don’t know the answers to the kids questions so they make the subject off limits so their stupidity wont show.

  • avatar

    Bob

    The Young Turks talked about this. It was not abstinence only. This clip explains it:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MiR73C_xFO8

  • avatar

    tina

    don’t engage in sexual activity until marrige its the best decision you can ever make. read it and weep.

  • avatar

    tory burch outlet store

    Hong Hyun body followed to Hong Xuan Yuan Goodness within and, Hong Xuan Yuan grok Miscellaneous together. Lord exclaimed, and then his confront was heavier. Hong Hyun like to know just about everything changes, the hearts of this tory burch flats only the existence of the sword, traces of the Path. Moving in a static, static in the go, yin and yang, reincarnation without a split.
    Outsider under this Jian Shi significantly cut into two areas, the LORD This Jian Qi topple! After all this, Hong Hyun close fretting hand, in the hands involving

Leave a Comment

Scroll to top