There are casualties in the struggle to answer the fundamental questions about the Universe. For a long time, it has been powerful religious institutions that have burned, sliced, chopped, eviscerated and snuffed opposing world views that undermined their own. Some may claim that the Inquisition and Crusades were political in nature, but it cannot be denied that strength of the the Churches power and the continued desire to maintain it’s foothold were the real motives behind these political moves. Their most powerful tool was the use of fear; the terrifying prospect of a world without their order and their mandate was too frightening to imagine.
Nowadays, the hold of Christianity is waning. Without the political control they once possessed, the focus has now been placed on creating fear that without them humanity faces nihilism and dread. It’s been repeated so often that most Christians literally believe that Atheists are somehow immoral, corrupt and perverse. This notion permeates our reputation, and is a powerful way to keep the flock from investigating the possibility that their religion may not be true.
Jesse Kilgore was a young man who struggled to figure out what to believe. After having read Richard Dawkin’s book, “The God Delusion”, he became depressed and morose. He believed that laws and ethics were not sacred but rather the product of societal convenience. Without the moral crutch of Christianity, he felt alone, isolated, and ultimately killed himself. His father, a highly religious man, feels that it is Atheism and Dawkins that are responsible for his death. Little does he know, however, that his entire belief system was a major part of the reason why Jesse took his own life.
Christians like to keep the stakes of belief high. Fail to believe in God, and the whole world falls apart. If human beings are animals, they claim, then all things are permissible. But if this was true, why are atheists on average more law abiding than their religious counterparts? Surely if no law is sacred, then why obey them at all? This false choice is a common tactic to bash Atheists. Laws and ethics do not need to be divine to be true, nor do human beings need the treat of Hell to ensure good behavior. What Jesse failed to realize was that there is an instinctual need to cooperate, to have friendships, and to love others. His religious upbringing made him feel as though he had nothing to live for if his faith was gone. There was no voice of reason to tell him that there is no need to feel nihilistic in the face of a Godless Universe.
Atheism isn’t a belief. It is simply the denial of god. What a person chooses to believe once a moral arbiter is removed is an individual decision. Most atheists choose to become humanists, trusting that human nature is cooperative and that life is both precious and rare precisely BECAUSE it developed and flourished on its own in a Universe that is hostile to organic life. Although it is true that some atheists can become nihilists, it is a belief that is an entirely self destructive belief system.
It’s sad that religious conservatives will use this death to continue to propose that having no religion is somehow cancerous to the human mind. If they perpetually raise the stakes in this manner, they may notice that their family and friends may be forced into such extremes that the only way out may be drastic. I do not claim that Atheism makes you more or less moral. It is merely a conviction on the non existence of God. I can no more control this instinct than I can control my need to drink water when i am thirsty. What is certain is that some human beings might be so shocked by this finding that they may be unable to cope with it. I would venture to say that the deep shock many highly religious people may face would be tempered if they realized that ethics and morality are not bound by absolutes. They are the work of fallible men and women that wished only to make the human race more successful and more peaceful, and despite what some religious people might tell you, I find this to be more beautiful and touching than any myth.


November 23rd, 2008 at 9:02 pm
nice post. the theist insistence that gawd’s the only source of morality, thus they’re good because they’re afraid of punishment, it one of the most grating of their beliefs…
it’s amazing that they can’t see how much harder, how much more selfless a moral life without god is.
good post.
November 24th, 2008 at 12:04 am
Great post! Having recently read Richard Dawkin’s book “The God Delusion” and coming from a Mormon background I would have to say that Atheist definitely fall more in line with what I believe (especially since Dawkin’s actually uses facts to support is arguments instead of just saying “well you just have to have faith”), but I always had a problem with the freedom “faith” gave people. (Anything that empowers people to say whatever they want and not support their claims with facts is dangerous, not to mention the absence of progression this would cause). Instead I was always told “Have faith and god will take care of the rest.” Well this doesn’t add up it lacks consistency, when comparing this to every other facet of life. Where people are accountable for what we say and we need to support these claims with facts. So why should religion be exempt from this? It is my firm belief that religion is for the weak. And for those who don’t think so think about all the advances in science we would have missed out on, and if these scientist used the religious “methodology”. We would be no where near where we are today. And just because we can’t disprove that god exist doesn’t mean that he does, furthermore to paraphrase what Dawkin says in “The God Delusion” “we are narrowing the gap.”
Thanks again for the post
November 24th, 2008 at 6:21 pm
Jake, honestly your articles make my life. It seems like every time I check the website there’s a new one.
November 24th, 2008 at 6:29 pm
I guess I can put you on the pre-order list for when i write my book, eh Jessica?
November 25th, 2008 at 11:03 pm
You can put me on that list too Jacob.